Broncos Quarterback Jay Cutler wants out of Denver so badly that he put the 7,500 square foot home he bought in 2006 up for sale. His inability to see eye to eye with new Broncos Coach Josh McDaniels -- even after a meeting, meant to clear up the situation -- has caused him to demand a trade. Over the past few days, Cutler has stuck to his guns; refusing to report to a team meeting and vocally expressing his displeasure with the circumstances. Cutler's outspokenness and stubbornness will influence the Broncos to trade him.
Viewing this situation as a Jets fan is intriguing, and the chance of acquiring Cutler is enticing. As a proponent of Brett Ratliff, I would much rather see Jay Cutler under center for New York. Cutler is as young as Ratliff, has NFL experience as a starter and is already a top 10 quarterback in the league. While I believe Ratliff can reach that same level of play, Cutler is already established.
The optimal deal for getting Cutler would be for the Jets to give up the 17th overall pick in this year's NFL Draft. As of now, the selection is up in the air, in terms of position. Quarterback has been talked about. The Jets are scheduled to hold private workouts for USC Quarterback Mark Sanchez and Kansas State's Josh Freeman. Wide Receiver is another need, with North Carolina's Hakeem Nicks and local favorite Kenny Britt of Rutgers due to be on the board in the late 1st round. Those are the only two glaring needs for the Jets (other than
punter).
If they could swing the first pick for Cutler, it would still leave the opportunity to select 2nd round talent at wide receiver, such as Rames Barden from Cal Poly.
However, Josh McDaniels stated "Other teams have called but we're not interested in getting draft picks for Jay.", seemingly ruling out the possibility of a trade for Cutler without giving up an impact player.
One possibility being floated around is a three-team deal involving Denver, New York and the Arizona Cardinals. This rumored trade would see Cutler going to the Jets, former first round pick and current Arizona backup QB Matt Leinart go to Denver along with the Jets' first round pick, and Arizona receiving the Broncos' second round selection and New York running back and Pro Bowl kick returner Leon Washington.
When negotiations reach the juncture of trading Leon Washington, that's where I turn sour on the deal. Washington is, without a doubt, the most explosive and dangerous weapon on the Jets offense -- arguably the entire team, when his kick return prowess is factored in. Last season, he carried the ball 76 times; not nearly enough for a player of his caliber. Through the underutilization, he still managed to amass 448 yards (5.9 yards a carry) and a career-high 6 touchdowns.
The presumed reason for his lack of carries was Eric Mangini's hold over the offense. Mangini, in order to appease Brett Favre, took over Brian Schottenheimer's play-calling duties to make the offense more pass-oriented. This switch in methods led to Washington receiving less carries on the ground; a place that he excelled in.
While the move to a pass-heavy offense took away from Washington's carries, he got a great amount of touches through the air. 47 receptions for 355 yards and 2 touchdowns is impressive, but he was still in need of touches. Washington cemented himself as the team's most explosive weapon, and still received amount of inadequate opportunities to make plays on offense. With the departure of Mangini, Washington will get more touches, thus making him even more effective.
If Leon Washington is subtracted from the offense, it will become less threatening and less efficient, even with Cutler on the team. While he can be a difference maker, a unique difference maker would be lost, and the offense would lose a key element, ultimately making it worse.
In addition to his incredible offensive ability, Leon Washington is also a top 3 kick returner in the league. Last year he was 10th in kick return yards with 1,231, 10th in yards per return with 25.6 and brought one kickoff to the house; numbers good enough to get him a nod to the 2008 Pro Bowl. He should have made the all-star game in 2007, when he filled in for Justin Miller, and proceeded to score 3 return touchdowns.
If Washington is dealt, there is no player currently on New York's roster nor in free agency that can duplicate his production. He is the perfect running back to spell Thomas Jones, and is integral to Jones' season if the 10-year veteran is to have his second-straight career year. Washington is the perfect change-of-pace coming off the bench; similar to Knicks' 6th Man Nate Robinson. Like Washington, Robinson can inject a much needed shot of energy into any game in just about any situation and for that, is priceless to the Knicks. Washington holds that same type of role on his team, making him as valuable to the Jets as Nate Robinson is to his team.
While a top 10 -- arguably top 5 -- quarterback is extremely valuable, Leon Washington has just as much value because he has proven that he can work well in Schottenheimer's offense and Mike Westhoff's special teams unit. Why take him out of two equations in favor of a player who is unknown to this system of play?
The Jets have two quarterback who are privy to Schottenheimer's system, and while Ratliff is not a proven player, like Cutler, he has the potential and skill set to reach that level, and if he is surrounded by this current Jets team, Ratliff can be launced to an above average status among NFL quarterbacks.
I know that I have lambasted the Knicks about waiting for 2010 and the possibility of signing LeBron James or Dwayne Wade, instead of building up a formittable team to compete now, and I have killed the Yankees for not signing Manny Ramirez and distancing themselves from the field. On paper, not getting Cutler seems like a similar thing that I have criticized teams for. But the acquisition of Cutler would be more than negated by a Leon Washington departure. If the Jets stick with what they have, they have a great chance at being better than they would be if they had brought Jay Cutler in.
Allow me to clarify once more. I definately want Jay Cutler in a New York Jets uniform, but not if that means a player as useful and significant as Leon Washington has to go.
--Max Caster